Comments on: American Idol Final – David Vs. David http://www.poptherapy.com/2008/05/american-idol-final-david-vs-david/ Pop culture news, celebrity gossip, movies, television, and satire. Tue, 27 Oct 2009 22:00:27 -0500 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.4 hourly 1 By: Panda http://www.poptherapy.com/2008/05/american-idol-final-david-vs-david/comment-page-1/#comment-7925 Panda Wed, 21 May 2008 03:41:02 +0000 http://www.poptherapy.com/?p=1410#comment-7925 Eh.. I'm for David Cook hands down. Not ONLY is he versatile, he has edge, a spark, AND a personality. Things that David A lacks. Every single time I watch American Idol, I can't help but to roll my eyes as his speeches. They seem like beauty pageant answers, all rehearsed and no meaning to them. You know.. the same "OH gosh! THANK YOU! I can't believe I made it this far." he's all about singing, no personality. People tell me it's because he's a kid but he's the same age I am, and I'm full with personality and voices my opinion, and when I say that, they reply quickly with, "He's in front of the nation. he's just shy. you would be too". Erm... no. I would be shy if it was my first time on stage, but the Idol Stage was not his first. Apparently, he was on stage at, I don't know.. as a kid he was on it? So should he be shy? No. He should be used to it. David Cook? He earns it. He has that spark. he appreciates it and he's always bringing something new. He's not doing the same ballad week after week (that means you, David A.), he's unpredictable but predictable in the same sense, but he's still shocking and amazing. My vote? David Cook. Eh.. I’m for David Cook hands down.
Not ONLY is he versatile, he has edge, a spark, AND a personality. Things that David A lacks.

Every single time I watch American Idol, I can’t help but to roll my eyes as his speeches. They seem like beauty pageant answers, all rehearsed and no meaning to them. You know.. the same “OH gosh! THANK YOU! I can’t believe I made it this far.” he’s all about singing, no personality. People tell me it’s because he’s a kid but he’s the same age I am, and I’m full with personality and voices my opinion, and when I say that, they reply quickly with, “He’s in front of the nation. he’s just shy. you would be too”. Erm… no. I would be shy if it was my first time on stage, but the Idol Stage was not his first. Apparently, he was on stage at, I don’t know.. as a kid he was on it? So should he be shy? No. He should be used to it.

David Cook? He earns it. He has that spark. he appreciates it and he’s always bringing something new. He’s not doing the same ballad week after week (that means you, David A.), he’s unpredictable but predictable in the same sense, but he’s still shocking and amazing.

My vote? David Cook.

]]> By: ron tattrie http://www.poptherapy.com/2008/05/american-idol-final-david-vs-david/comment-page-1/#comment-7279 ron tattrie Thu, 15 May 2008 05:34:11 +0000 http://www.poptherapy.com/?p=1410#comment-7279 I would have to agree,it would have made next week worth watching if kristy and syesha were the two left for next week.david a doesn't have the experience or stage presence and i would sure hate to think my grandaughters would not have someone better than david c to look to as an idol.this contest becomes a popularity contest after the judges have done their job and given us 24 very competent performers.the biggest fault after that is the voting process that allows any bored person to spend 2 hrs.hitting redial.hardly party to the democratic process. I would have to agree,it would have made next week worth watching if kristy and syesha were the two left for next week.david a doesn’t have the experience or stage presence and i would sure hate to think my grandaughters would not have someone better than david c to look to as an idol.this contest becomes a popularity contest after the judges have done their job and given us 24 very competent performers.the biggest fault after that is the voting process that allows any bored person to spend 2 hrs.hitting redial.hardly party to the democratic process.

]]>